Best Tough Tablets for 2021-2022: The Nuffield Technologies Guide

Best Tough Tablets for 2021-2022: The Nuffield Technologies Guide

It’s easy to see the appeal of tough tablets. They offer far more screen space than a rugged mobile phone but are also more portable and adaptable in the field than a rugged laptop.

The Nuffield Technologies Best Tough Tablets for 2021-2022 guide reveals our top recommendations. We’ve tried to present a broad cross-section in terms of price and functionality, so wherever you’re coming from – education, logistics, construction, pharma, defence or public sector – there will be something for you.

As for the tough factor, if you’ve landed on this page you may be convinced of the benefits of rugged devices already. But a quick recap: they’re going to be durable in the field and survive knocks and drops, typically have longer lifespans and better power management than consumer devices (and often extraordinarily good maintenance plans), and an ecosystem of add-ons such as carry straps and barcode readers that further increase functionality.

All of the tablets on this page have excellent MIL-STD rugged credentials and an IP (Ingress Protection) rating of 65 or higher unless otherwise specified. You can find more about these international rugged standards here.

Without further ado, here’s the guide.

Panasonic Toughbook G2: the versatile tablet ideal for data-sensitive industries

Image source: Panasonic
  • Cost: ££££
  • OS: Windows 10 Pro, upgradeable to Windows 11
  • Weight: 1.19kg
  • Maintenance plan: 3 year warranty out of the box with options to extend to 5 years and for accidental damage
  • Notable feature: Optional keyboard for two-in-one functionality
  • Room for improvement? Trackpad on optional keyboard could be better

Our review:

For some industries, heightened security will be just as important as ruggedness – think the police, emergency services and defence. That’s where the Panasonic Toughbook G2 is a great choice. It features biometric user authentication, a Microsoft Windows Secured-Core PC and – the standout feature – a quick-release SSD so the hard drive can be safely stored away.

But it’s more than security performance that makes this one of the most hard-working tough tablets. There’s an optional keyboard, to provide instant laptop functionality; an optional hot-swap battery; impressive screen brightness; and plenty of hardware modules to tailor this device to your requirements, including options for a contact smart card reader, thermal camera, extended batteries and additional ports. The Panasonic Toughbook G2 runs on a 10th Gen Intel Core processor with Intel vPro technology and 16GB ram, with an option to outfit it to 32GB. One feature that owners of earlier versions will appreciate is backwards compatibility with the G1’s accessories, so you can keep using existing hardware and avoid unnecessary expense on new peripherals.

Samsung Galaxy Tab Active 3 (8-inch display): the well-built device with adaptable screen options – great for presentations

Image source: Consumer Reports
  • Cost: £
  • OS: Android 10
  • Weight: 429g
  • Maintenance plan: 24/7 Enterprise Technical Support available, including device replacement and on-site support in some cases
  • Notable feature: Samsung DeX
  • Room for improvement? Screen is fairly small

Our review:

The feature that most catches our eye about this reasonably priced tablet is Samsung DeX. This lets you simply connect two different screens, so your tablet instantly accommodates multiple document viewing – for instance, when accessing a spreadsheet on one screen and writing up a report on the other. You can use this DeX functionality to connect to a smart TV, to give impressive reports or presentations – a great feature for managers and sales teams. Or attach a keyboard and mouse and switch to ‘DeX mode’, and you can use your tablet just like a PC: open multiple windows, drag and drop, right-click etc. This really does unlock a whole new level of functionality for a tablet.

Tough tablets at this price won’t match the leaders in the market, but the Tab Active 3 is still a hard-working device. It’s sturdy, with an IP68 rating and MIL-STD 80H; it features replaceable batteries and you can even plug in and work without a battery; the screen performs well with gloves on; and the 13mp camera uses Google ARCore to track motion and sense surroundings, ideal for hands-on augmented reality training or technical support. The device runs on a Samsung Exynos 9810 processor paired with 4GB Ram and 64 GB internal storage. At just 429g, it’s surprisingly light, too.

Getac K120-EX: the ultimate military-grade tablet for extreme conditions – handles even explosive environments

Image source: Getac
  • Cost: £££££
  • OS: Windows 10 Pro
  • Weight: 1.76kg
  • Maintenance plan: Industry-leading three-year warranty
  • Notable feature: ATEX certified (functionality in explosive environments)
  • Room for improvement? Very costly device

Our review:

According to the marketing, the Getac K120-EX has ‘more power, more connectivity and more convenience’. All of that may be true, it is a mighty machine (and more on its specs in a moment) but the one feature that will stand out for many is its ATEX and IECEx Zone 2/22 certification. This helps to ensure safe functionality in potentially explosive environments (think flammable gases, mists, vapours or combustible dust) because it will not generate sparks and potentially trigger explosions. If you work in industrial manufacturing, oil and gas, or even logistics, this may be a very important feature for you.

On to the power and connectivity part: the latest generation Intel Core processor helps it undertake multiple tasks without overheating and the Intel Iris Xe graphics will let you see more impressive visuals with less battery drain. Its compatibility with 4G/LTE, and the new Wi-Fi 6 (802.11ax) standard makes for smooth mobile connectivity and more bandwidth. The device has solid security credentials, too, with multifactor hardware and software security options and a removable SSD.

Lenovo 10e Chromebook: the ultimate tough tablets for kids (and the workplace)

Image source: Tech Inn
  • Cost: £
  • OS: Chrome OS
  • Weight: Approx 0.5 kg
  • Maintenance plan: None available
  • Notable feature: Nice and light
  • Room for improvement? Low memory and storage

Our review:

Although the Lenovo 10e Chromebook is often marketed at schools, this tough tablet is a also a great choice for businesses. It has a robust profile and plenty of functionality – and comes at a competitive price. The MediaTek MT8183 processor will keep videos playing (and recording) and the FHD (full high definition) screen is sharp and bright enough for outdoor work. It's nice and light, and Dragontail Glass is scratch resistant with outstanding strength.

The Chrome OS is intuitive and will fit seamlessly into environments using Chrome / Google Workspace. Meanwhile, the ten-hour battery life will be more than enough for most shifts. On the rugged side, we can’t find an IP (ingress protection) rating, but almost all other reviews do attest to its durability and suitability for kids- and if it can withstand being handled by children, it should do well in a work environment. Security support is available until 2028.

On the downside, the speakers barely scrape a pass and the optional keyboard attachment lacks a trackpad, which means it can’t operate in true laptop mode. Still, weighing up the pros and cons, the Lenovo 10e Chromebook is a great tablet for work that won’t break the bank.

Zebra XSlate L10 Rugged Tablet: Our STAR BUY

Image source: Zebra

Cost: ££££

  • OS: Windows 10 Pro; or Android 10 upgradeable through Android 12
  • Weight: 1.3kg
  • Maintenance plan: OneCare maintenance plans offer guaranteed: next business day, three-day and five-day repair turnarounds
  • Notable feature: Fantastic brightness levels; great for outdoor use
  • Room for improvement? Speakers may struggle in very noisy environments

Our review:

This durable, rugged machine will handle just about anything you can throw at it. The Zebra XSlate L10 comes in a number of processor options and each is blazingly fast, handling multiple tasks with ease. It provides super-fast wireless connections via WiFi, Bluetooth, cellular, GPS and NFC. Meanwhile, the hot-swappable battery is going to go on and on for up to 27 hours if you choose the extended version. Also, it comes with either Windows or Android, which means there’s a good chance you’ll be choosing a tablet that instantly feels familiar.

These alone tick off some of the key wish list items for most tablet users, but it offers so much more. Firstly, there’s that famous Zebra ecosystem of accessories to raise functionality still further: the keyboard instantly turns it into a laptop and the barcode reader will increase its usefulness for warehouse and logistics operations.

The security support and maintenance plans will never leave you hanging – with a OneCare contract you get up to 10 years of security support and various options for quick repair turnaround. It’s not cheap but, still, from a return on investment point of view, you’re always going to be thinking this is great value for money.

Zebra ET56 Rugged Tablet (8-inch display): a light, consumer-style tablet with strong rugged credentials

Image source: Zebra
  • Cost: £££
  • OS: Windows 10 Pro; or Android 11 upgradeable through Android 14
  • Weight: 570g
  • Maintenance plan: OneCare maintenance plans offer guaranteed: next business day, three-day and five-day repair turnarounds
  • Notable feature: Sleek, consumer-style profile
  • Room for improvement? Some may find the screen a bit small

Our review:
There’s no other way of putting it: some of the hardest-working tough tablets are a bit on the bulky side. That is a description you’ll never give to the ET56. The 8in display version of this rugged tablet packs the punch and durability you’d expect from a Zebra machine and yet it has the slim, sleek and light profile of a consumer model.

Whether you choose the Windows or the Android version, it will almost certainly have the processing speed to handle what you’re going to throw at it. The Android version runs on a Qualcomm Snapdragon 660 octa-core 2.2 GHz; the Windows on Intel Atom E3940 quad-core 1.6 GHz (Turbo Frequency = 1.8 GHz).

It has plenty of connectivity options too, including powerful Wi-Fi and top of the line Bluetooth with a range of more than 100 metres.

As with the XSlate L10, the screen is readable in even strong daylight and this is a great model for adding a barcode reader from Zebra’s huge range of accessories and add-ons.

As with other Zebra models, a OneCare maintenance plan delivers up to 10 years of security support and exceptional support and repairs.

Our blog has lots more expert advice on rugged devices to help you find the right model for your business. Read about the best tough phones, the importance of calculating the total cost of ownership before buying a device, and the pros and cons of a bring your own device policy for your business.

Best Tough Phones for 2021-2022: The Nuffield Technologies Guide

Man in high-vis and hard hat using a tough phone

Tough phones – or ‘rugged’ phones to use the industry terminology – should cope with the knocks, drops and general abuse handed out in a business environment. But, just as there are many business environments and requirements, there are many tough phones out there to choose from.

Our Best Tough Phones for 2021-2022 guide gives you a snapshot of what we think are among the most impressive out there right now. We’ve tried to highlight some of the key features, so you can quickly focus on a phone that might be a perfect fit for your workforce. We’ve also tried to include a broad price range to cater for different budgets.

Before continuing, here’s a little housekeeping on what we mean by ‘tough’ or ‘rugged’.

● All of our featured devices comply to at least MIL-STD 810g, which proves they have survived multiple drops from four feet.

● Most devices, apart from where indicated, comply to at least an Ingress Protection rating IP68, which suggests they can withstand dust, dirt and sand, and are resistant to submersion up to a maximum depth of 1.5m underwater for up to 30 minutes.

You can find out more about rugged classifications here.

Meanwhile, all devices run on the Android OS. We think it’s the best choice for business and you can find out why here.

Finally, we’ve indicated if a phone includes optional maintenance contracts and, where possible, the amount of time it takes for the manufacturer to guarantee a fix. Without these contracts, you may need to take your chances with a local repair.

Here’s the list of Best Tough Phones 2021-2022.

Samsung XCover Pro: the affordable all-rounder that’s great for outdoor workers

Samsung XCover Pro front and back
Image source: Samsung
  • Cost: £
  • OS: Android 10, upgradable to Android 11
  • Security support: At least four years from 2020 launch
  • Maintenance plan: Not available
  • Notable feature: Large, attractive display
  • Room for improvement? Processor lacks punch and minimal storage

Our review:

Measure the Samsung XCover Pro against any rugged or tough phones checklist and it ticks so many boxes. It has wet touch and glove mode, and can even be used with standard gloves. It features two programmable buttons, which you can use to quickly start up an app. There’s push-to-talk for challenging comms environments (although this needs to be combined with other software, for example Microsoft teams, to make it work). There are even pogo pins, which means it will support docked charging – always a bonus in busy environments. Add the sleek design, easy-on-the-eye 6.3in display and the fact it takes card payments and there’s a huge amount going for this affordable rugged all-rounder.

When you get under the hood, we would quibble – at least a little. The 2.3GHz processor powered by the in-house Exynos 9611 chip isn’t going to rock many worlds in terms of speed. Just 4GB of RAM and 64GB of onboard storage feels a bit on the modest side too. Also, a tired battery can be changed, but you do need to pry off the back cover to install a new one. Finally, the screen does struggle a little bit in bright daylight. That said, it’s a solid rugged performer at a great price.

CAT S62 PRO Smartphone: the thermal camera phone with a super tough profile

Front and back of CAT s62 PRO tough smartphone
Image source: Cat
  • Cost: ££
  • OS: Android 10
  • Security support: Up to three years from 2020 launch
  • Maintenance plan: Not available
  • Notable feature: Detects elevated body temperatures
  • Room for improvement? No replaceable battery feature

Our review:

The standout feature on this phone is the impressive FLIR thermal imaging camera. This will detect heat sources up to 10 feet away, to help you locate heat, draft hotspots and heatloss, making it an asset in industries from law enforcement and leak detection to electrical inspection and housing surveys. It will even screen people for elevated temperatures, helping to fulfill a very urgent need, given the pandemic. One other thing you’ve got to love is the sheer ruggedness of this tough phone. Manufacturers say it will survive six feet drops onto concrete and it is IP68 and IP69 rated, giving it superior ingress protection. Add a decent screen-size and excellent screen visibility and you have a great phone for the construction industry, for example, although other industries will like it too.

The camera is so-so at best – at least compared to similarly priced phones – and one thing we don’t love is the battery set up. You can’t take off the back cover and replace a depleted battery for a new one, which, in the worst-case scenario, could see work and productivity grind to a halt.

If this isn’t likely to be an issue for you – i.e. charging points will be available nearby – all in all, it is a great phone.

Point Mobile PM45 Ultra Rugged Smartphone – the entry level tough phone with great push-to-talk functionality

Point Mobile PM45 Ultra Rugged Smartphone front and back
Image source: Point Mobile
  • Cost: £
  • OS: Android 8.1 and upgradeable to Android 9
  • Security support: Seven years from release date
  • Maintenance plan: UK-based repair plans available
  • Notable feature: Convenient hard keys for quick access to apps
  • Room for improvement? IP rating lower than other models, OS is out of date.

Our review:

This tough phone anticipates even the loudest, most challenging industrial environment – and does everything it can to keep you talking. The PM45 brings ease to the push-to-talk experience with a large tactile side button, a powerful speaker, an external push-to- talk remote speaker microphone so you can talk without holding your phone, and headset support. It also features three hard keys for the standard Android buttons, which is increasingly unusual but can be useful when wearing gloves. The phone is billed as pretty snappy too, with a 1.8GHz Octa-core processor.

Businesses will be grateful for features that keep their tough phones working hard, such as options for dockable charging and replaceable batteries. You can also choose an extended-life battery.

Naturally, at this price point you won’t see the performance of more costly, powerful phones and its IP67 Ingress Protection rating lags a little behind (although this will be a high enough rating for most users). But it is a great entry-level buy.

Sonim RS60 Mobile Computer and Smart Scanner – the barcode reader with plenty more to give

Sonim RS60 Mobile Computer and Smart Scanner
Image source: Sonim Technologies
  • Cost: £££
  • OS: Android 10
  • Security support: Five years of support from 2021 launch
  • Maintenance plan: Not available
  • Notable feature: A HUGE battery capacity
  • Room for improvement? On the heavy side

Our review:

There are times when a barcode-reading app using a standard camera just isn’t going to cut it. Enter the Sonim RS60. Its integrated barcode scanner features quick-scan capabilities that will rapidly capture large amounts of data (30 scans per second, including degraded barcodes). But it’s more than a scanner. This smartphone-style device has a large 6in display that is readable in sunlight, making it ideal for calls and all your comms needs. Nice enterprise touches include the glove-friendly mode, anti-fingerprint coating, support for docked charging and a whopper of a battery – it’s 8000mAh, the largest we’ve encountered. It can be swopped too.

Our quibbles with this device is that the camera isn’t great and it is pretty weighty – of course, the huge battery and barcode scanner will see to that. It’s also IP67 rated, not IP68 like many of the other featured devices. Having said that, it’s a great enterprise scanner / phone that’s going to suit many in warehouses, logistics and manufacturing.

Zebra TC57 Touch Computer – our STAR BUY rugged device

Zebra TC57 Touch Computer
Image source: Zebra Technologies
  • Cost: ££££
  • OS: Android 10, with upgrade support to at least Android 11
  • Security support: Up to 8 years support with OneCare contract
  • Maintenance plan: OneCare maintenance plans offer guaranteed next business day, three-day and five-day repair turnarounds
  • Notable feature: Eco-system of Zebra software, accessories and support
  • Room for improvement? Other devices are prettier

Our review:

If we tell you that the Zebra series of tough phones are the Rolls Royce / Ferrari (take your pick) of the tough phone market, you’ll realise we are sold on these models. And for good reason. The phones are one of the most rugged devices in their class and the only with a unibody design, which provides extra impact protection for sensitive electronics. They feature next-gen Wi-Fi 6, for extremely fast connectivity and low latency, and the fastest processor in the enterprise market at 2.45 GHz, paired with 4GB RAM/32GB UFS fast memory. The barcode reader features a SE4720 scan engine for faster, easier capture of even the most challenging barcodes. The crystal-clear 5in fully HD touch screen can be used with gloves or a stylus. There’s push-to-talk functionality and impressive 14 hours of battery life with hot swappable batteries. Also, this device features Zebra’s Mobility DNA, which enhances Android’s system for tighter security, easier centralised management and seamless app development. We could go on…

However, it’s the ecosystem around the devices that will ensure they stand the test of time. There is a full suite of cradles and car charging accessories, and also very targeted devices such as pistol grip snap for barcode reading which can significantly increase efficiency. These are all forwards compatible, extending your investment when you need to replace devices. You can also rest easy with excellent, long-term security support and a OneCare maintenance plan that swiftly repairs and returns devices.

What don’t we like so much? The smooth finish can make the device feel a little less secure in the hand than its premium range counterpart, the Zebra TC7X series, but if it’s functionality and ROI that matter most to you, there’s nothing to see here in terms of negatives.

Zebra TC26 Touch Computer – ‘The Best Budget Device on the Market’

Zebra TC26 Touch Computer
Image source: Zebra Technologies
  • Cost ££
  • OS: Android 10, with upgrade support to at least Android 11
  • Security support: Up to 10 years support with OneCare contract
  • Maintenance plan: OneCare maintenance plans offers guaranteed next business day, three-day and five-day repair turnarounds
  • Notable feature: Eco-system of Zebra software, accessories and support
  • Room for improvement? You’ll need an add-on for heavy scanning

Our review:

Imagine you want to make a move away from low-cost, low-performing devices (and you definitely should) to a model that will be a gear change in terms of optimising efficiency. However, you can’t significantly increase your budget. Probably the smartest choice you could make is the Zebra TC26 Touch Computer. It offers more options than any device in its class in terms of battery, connectivity, RAM and scanning accessories, so you can almost certainly find something for your business and your budget. It has a great 5in HD screen you can use with gloves on, superior voice quality and functionality, and comes ready to use Push-to-Talk Express. You can scan with the hi-res 13MP rear camera or, for heavier scanning, add one of a range of scanners suitable for your needs. The battery is removable and there are 10 hour and 14 hour options.

The Zebra TC26 is a significant improvement on the previous generation model, the TC25, and is a seriously impressive device at this price point.

As with the TC57, the ecosystem around this device is exceptional. There are masses of accessories to boost productivity (check out the RS5100 Bluetooth ring scanner for a complete hands-free solution), single and multi-slot chargers, wearable carrying solutions and much more. Mobility DNA tools will enhance security and manageability, and Zebra’s exceptional OneCare plan will ensure your devices are repaired promptly and your people keep working.

Want to delve further into the tough phone market? Download our white paper ‘Consumer Vs Enterprise: Why choosing consumer devices for your business might cost you more than you think.’ It will lead you step by step through the rugged phone market, helping you decide which features should be crucial in your decision-making when choosing a device.

Why Calculating Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) is Crucial Before Purchasing Business Mobile Devices

Warehouse worker scanning barcode with rugged mobile device

One way of calculating the cost of mobile technology for your business is to compare the prices of devices. The cheaper models, you might reasonably assume, will cost you less and those savings will be magnified as you purchase tens or even hundreds of devices for your business.

The truth, to use a well-worn phrase, is a little more complicated than that. In fact, any true budgeting exercise for mobile devices will also look at costs beyond the initial outlay. These will include things like software, system design, training and downtime as a result of failure.

Welcome to the world of total cost of ownership. It will shine a bright light on every aspect of your mobile investment, so you can come away with a true understanding of what you’ll be paying when comparing one device with another.

Here’s what you’ll need to consider.

Total cost of ownership includes hard costs and soft costs

This key distinction is at the heart of making an intelligent choice when choosing mobile devices. Hard costs are your upfront fees such as hardware, software, and system design and integration. Soft costs are ‘hidden’ costs (in the sense that you might not initially consider them) such as training, operational requirements and downtime as a result of device failure.

There are two things worth pointing out in relation to the graphic below.

Firstly, hard costs go way beyond device procurement. There are many things to consider, such as accessories and peripherals, and software development costs.

Secondly, soft costs are going to be significantly greater than hard costs.

The market intelligence and consulting firm VDC Research has shown that soft costs will account for at least four fifths of the total cost of ownership of a device. In other words, comparing one upfront price of a device against another is only scratching the surface of the true cost of ownership.

Diagram showing reasons total cost of ownership is higher for consumer devices than rugged in enterprise environments
Consumer devices increase total cost of ownership in enterprise environments.

Rugged devices are going to significantly reduce those soft costs

There’s another statistic we’d like to share with you. VDC Research shows that over 50% of the total costs of using a mobile phone or tablet in an enterprise environment are the result of lost worker productivity due to device failure.

Therefore, when considering total cost of ownership, you will inevitably want to choose a tough rugged device over a consumer model. We’ve talked in another post about what makes rugged devices truly durable. In a nutshell, compared to consumer models they offer greater resistance to: shocks and drops, liquid and particle ingress, and extreme temperatures. Conversely, consumer devices are far more fragile and fail 2.9 times more often than rugged phones and tablets. This can have disastrous consequences for businesses in terms of worker downtime, morale, lost revenue and reputational damage.

There are many more factors to consider when looking at how rugged models will help reduce soft costs compared to consumer models. These relate to issues around repairs and maintenance, software integration, battery life and charging, use of add-ons, and support and security. We’ve written at length about these elements in a post that looks at why consumer devices constantly fail businesses compared to rugged models. It’s definitely worth a read alongside this article to give you an in-depth look at the issues, to help you make the right investment in terms of TCO.

However, busy readers might like to cut straight to some numbers that quickly and convincingly put the case for rugged models over consumer devices in terms of total cost of investment.

A rugged versus consumer comparison: the statistics

VDC Research undertook an analysis of the total cost of ownership for mobile devices when supporting line of business applications. They looked at the cost of upfront acquisition, deployment, training, support and productivity loss caused by downtime.

Over a five-year period, they calculated that non-rugged handheld devices cost £16,459.66 per device and rugged devices £7,771.36. This means that rugged devices have a 52.7% lower total cost of ownership than consumer devices over five years.

Here’s how to calculate total cost of ownership

At this point, you’ll have a more comprehensive understanding of total cost of ownership and what it takes to price your mobile device investment. Hopefully, you’ll also be convinced of the benefits of rugged over consumer devices in terms of TCO.

But what if your situation is a little more complicated? For instance, one of your chosen models may have some rugged features, or you may need to compare two rugged models.

This is where Zebra Technologies’ TCO Calculator and Reporting Tool can come in useful. Working with a Zebra device reseller such as Nuffield Technologies, businesses can use the tool to establish hard and soft costs over time. We can help you directly compare two devices, providing information on the expected lifecycle according to your specific business scenario. The calculator provides detailed results by cost category and cost year, as well as cumulative project costs and considerations beyond TCO.

This consultation and report from Nuffield Technologies is completely free. To find out more, contact us on info@nuffieldtechnologies.com.

If you’d like to learn more about total cost of ownership and the differences between consumer and rugged mobiles, you can download our white paper ‘Consumer Versus Enterprise: Why Choosing Consumer Devices for Your Business Might Cost You More than You Think’.

Is Bring Your Own Device (BYOD) a Good Idea for your Business?

Employee using a BYOD phone at work

It’s an eye-catching concept from the point of view of employers.

Bring your own device (BYOD) encourages employees to use their own phones or tablets to access work systems and data. One 2018 study showed that 31 per cent of businesses rely on workers to use personal devices. Fifty two per cent have a hybrid approach, with some team members using corporate phones and others their own devices.

Advocates suggest that increased productivity, and better recruitment and retention are all within reach by adopting this approach. Perhaps most significantly, BYOD businesses don’t need to shell out on phones, because their employees provide the kit.

Construction worker at work using her own mobile device
BYOD policies are appealing for both businesses and employees, but they are not without their drawbacks.

At this point, any business owner or IT manager with a reasonable dose of scepticism is probably asking: What’s the catch? And, yes, in our view, while there are some compelling arguments for BYOD, there are significant catches – and costs – you’ll want to consider before going down this route.

So, should your business join the BYOD ‘revolution’? Here are the pros and cons.

BYOD: the pros

Cost

BYOD shifts the device costs away from the business to the user. This is going to save money – possibly even considerable sums – when procuring technology, because organisations are not paying for the hardware.

Productivity

According to a report at forbes.com, using portable devices for work saves employees 50 minutes each day and increases productivity by 34%. Part of the reason for increased efficiency, according to IBM, is that if you are familiar with a device and like using it (highly likely with a device of your own choosing) you’re going to be more productive. Employees themselves back up these findings. Forbes says that 61 per cent of millennial workers think personal tools are more effective and productive than work ones. Individuals are also going to replace devices faster than businesses will replace whole fleets, meaning they are more likely to be holding the latest technology.

Employee retention and recruitment

BYOD brings businesses a lot of brownie points with employees and potential hires. According to professional services network Deloitte, 83% of skilled workers with access to flexible IT policies (including the option to bring their own device) are satisfied with their work. This is compared with 62% of those who are not enjoying flexible IT conditions. Meanwhile, 44% of jobseekers view an organisation more positively if it has a BYOD policy.

Some commentators have argued that, because smartphones are so ubiquitous now, trying to tell an employee which device to use is a bit like telling them which pen to use: it feels controlling and doesn’t go down well. It’s a compelling point.

Public services worker using own mobile device at work
BYOD can work well because people may have strong preferences on their choice of mobile phone.

BYOD: the cons

Security

How do you ensure employees follow safe security protocols as part of a BYOD policy? This happens to be the 16 million dollar question.

AN IDG survey revealed that more than half of 1600 senior IT managers, security and tech purchase decision-makers had reported serious violations of personal device use. Employees might be visiting risky sites, or using their device on unprotected public Wi-Fi networks at home or in public spaces. In either case, this could make them – and your company data – prey to hackers.

Other important security issues include:

  • Lost or stolen devices. Lost, stolen or misplaced devices could end up in the hands of criminals, putting your systems, data and business in jeopardy. This is particularly the case if users are left to set their own passwords (or not set them at all, as is so often the case)
  • Company leavers. Sometimes colleagues leave abruptly, which means you may not have time to wipe a device of corporate passwords and information – and they may be able to access sensitive information after they are gone
  • Not updating software. If your BYOD strategy makes users responsible for updating the software on their own phones, some people aren’t going to do it. Also, with most consumer phones only receiving security updates for three years, some will not be able to keep their phone secure even if they want to.

Moral and legal issues

BYOD opens up some tricky issues, blurring the boundaries in terms of responsibilities and work/personal time.

For instance, if your employee breaks their device do they bear the cost or do you? And if it is their responsibility, what if they say they can’t afford to get a new one?

Meanwhile, with a BYOD approach, can you ensure your employees’ personal time is not being infringed, or they are not being monitored when you have no right to be tracking their movements?

You’ll need to discuss proper terms with management, individual teams, legal and IT departments, with close scrutiny of any applicable employment laws. And don’t be one of those employers that kicks these issues into the long grass. According to one survey, only 39% of employers have a formal BYOD policy.

Lack of functionality / not fit for purpose

There’s one other crucial issue you’ll want to look at when considering a BYOD policy: will your teams’ own devices provide the functionality you need?

For instance, consumer devices are a world away from built-for-business rugged devices. The latter offers:

  • Greater durability. They will survive knocks and drops
  • Ingress protection from fluids and solids. Use them in the rain, no problem
  • Better battery functionality, to keep your people working for longer
  • More comprehensive and long-lasting support for software and hardware issues. (Can you really wait for an employee to sort that repair?)
  • Mobile device management. You can control and update many devices centrally
  • And many more benefits

We’ve written a detailed account of what makes a phone rugged here. Also, for a closer look at why consumer phones fail in enterprise environments, read this post.

We’d encourage you to look at them both as they are very pertinent to the BYOD story.

Construction worker using a consumer mobile device at work
Many businesses have BYOD policies, but are personal mobile devices fit for the work environment?

Conclusion

BYOD will work for some businesses. In our view, however, many of the flashier benefits will be tempered by the reality of putting employees’ own devices at the centre of your operations. The stark truth is that they will fail far more often than company-owned rugged devices – and that will cost you in terms of productivity and profits far more than any outlay on devices ever would.

You should also consider the potential cost of a data breach as a result of vulnerabilities caused by BYOD. The median cost of a breach for a small business (defined as 10-49 employees) is $13,125, according to The Hiscox Cyber Readiness Report 2021.

Use BYOD if you must, but safeguard your business by:

  • Ensuring devices are equipped with passcodes or fingerprint unlocking as mandatory, preferably including 2FA
  • Implementing a mobile device management solution that allows you to remotely wipe business data from employees' phones
  • Considering solutions that separate work and personal data on your employees' devices, such as Android work profiles, Samsung Knox or Google Workspace

Better still, consider purchasing or upgrading your own fleet of devices. You’ll bring more benefits to your organisation, experience fewer technical hitches or downtime, and your company will be more protected from the bad guys.

Find out more about the differences between consumer and enterprise-level devices in our white paper Consumer Vs Enterprise: Why choosing consumer devices for your business might cost you more than you think.

9 Reasons Why Your Business Mobile Devices Are Failing (And What You Can Do About It)

9 Reasons Why Your Business Mobile Devices Are Failing (And What You Can Do About It)

One of the biggest mistakes made by businesses buying technology is choosing consumer mobile devices instead of rugged ones.

That’s a pretty bold statement, but the facts bear it out. The failure rate of consumer devices is 2.9 times higher than enterprise phones [1]. In other words, organisations are using business mobile devices that are not up to the task. They are paying for this mistake in lost productivity due to device failure, and in the need to regularly replace defective handsets; anecdotal evidence suggests that workers frequently break as many as five phones in three years.

But why are these consumer mobile devices failing? We look at nine ways they fall short for businesses. We’d encourage you to think about which of these failures might apply now or in the future for your organisation. And then consider carefully before purchasing cheaper consumer phones over rugged models ­–­ because, as you’ll see, they will cost you far more in the long run.

Why consumer devices fail:

1) They can’t take the shocks and drops

Rugged phones are designed to conform to MIL-STD, a rugged classification system for shocks and drops designed by the US military. During testing, they will be dropped from four feet up to 27 times, including on the edges and corners. They survive because their casings and, crucially, internal components are designed to withstand this harsh treatment. Consumer phones will not meet as high a standard. When they fall, they will often break. Even if you pair them with a rugged case.

2) They can’t take the heat (or cold)

You may not have heard of ‘thermal throttling’, but any of your people working in hot environments using non-rugged business mobile devices will know its effects. In this scenario, your phone’s CPU gets hot and automatically slows down to reduce the heat. Your employees, meanwhile, get less work done. Conversely, extreme cold can cause your touch screen to become unresponsive and the battery drain more quickly. Your phone might even shut down unexpectedly. Not so good for employees working in refrigeration, or extremely cold weather. Rugged models, meanwhile, commonly withstand ranges from -20 °C to 50 °C (-4 °F to 122 °F ).

3) They let in liquids and small particles

Everyone has their story about dropping their phone into water, or perhaps getting it covered in sand. It rarely has a happy ending. That’s because consumer phones are unlikely to have the high IP (ingress protection) rating of rugged phones, which can see them withstand water jets, total immersion and tiny particles. Find out more about all of these first three points in our post What Makes a Rugged Mobile ‘Rugged’.

Wet business mobile device
Getting it wet can often mean the end of life for consumer phones.

4) They run out of battery too quickly

A modern phone’s battery functions for two to three years before it starts dropping charge by around 20 per cent. This drop increases the chance your workers will be left high and dry with powered-down phones. These days, it’s impossible to change the battery on many consumer phones, meaning the only option is to replace the device. If you’re a rugged phone user, however, you can switch the battery and work uninterrupted. Many rugged device users can also ‘hot swap’ batteries – replace a depleted battery with a charged one without powering down the device.

5) They are supported for only a limited time

Most consumer devices have a limited warranty and support for only a few years, and accidental damage is unlikely to be covered. After this relatively short period, your business mobile devices will be left high and dry in terms of support and repairs. In this scenario, businesses are essentially living on a knife-edge hoping nothing goes wrong, because there will be no one there to fix devices.

Rugged devices are designed so repairs, parts and peripherals are available for as long as 10 years [1]. Also, the support provided by rugged manufacturers can be incredibly comprehensive. For instance, Zebra’s OneCare range of plans will fix whatever issues you are having with devices and software rapidly, so you won’t need to endure costly shutdowns while waiting for a solution.

6) They are not necessarily secure

The limited support mentioned above also relates to security updates. Consumer Watchdog estimates that 20 per cent of Android devices no longer receive vital security updates from Google, leaving them open to malware and other security breaches [1]. On average, these breaches cost £11,000 per incident for small businesses [1]. Of course, you could replace all devices every two to three years, which would significantly increase the total cost of ownership. Or you could invest in a rugged device, where support and security updates are available for up to 10 years.

Chart showing rugged business mobile devices are secure for longer
Many rugged device manufacturers offer support and security updates for up to 10 years so your devices stay in service for as long as possible.

7) They may struggle to support accessories

Take one consumer device and add barcode and RFID scanning hardware, mobile printing accessories and vehicle-mounting devices and you have an increasingly versatile piece of technology. You’re also going to pay a lot for these add-ons which, in many cases, may already be integrated or included with a rugged device at the time of purchase.

Even when you do need to buy accessories for a rugged device, they are likely to be a far better investment than when buying similar add ons for consumer models. This is because – unlike most consumer devices – rugged devices are designed for backwards compatibility. When you upgrade your devices, all of the accessories will not suddenly become defunct – you’ll be able to continue using them. This makes far better business sense and reduces the total cost of ownership when compared to consumer devices.

8) Their features may not be fit for purpose

The name of the game with any device for business has to be productivity. But what if your consumer device appears to have the functionality of a rugged counterpart, but in truth isn’t performing to anywhere near the same degree? A classic example is the barcode scanner. Yes, consumer device cameras can often be used as barcode scanners, and that might be a solution for you. But a consumer camera will never pick up codes as quickly or efficiently as purpose-built tech. In fact, rugged devices with built in barcode scanners are a different beast altogether. The expanded working range and wide field of view allows workers to scan barcodes nearer and farther away, while omnidirectional scanning delivers true point-and-shoot performance – there is no need to align the device with the barcode.

9) They fail to charge properly

One of the biggest points of failure for consumer devices is the charging mechanism: fragile pins are inserted in and out of chargers repeatedly, get damaged and work intermittently or fail. This can be disastrous for businesses, resulting in more downtime and more failing devices. Rugged devices use industrial charging solutions that remove the need for cables and fragile pins. They are backward and forward compatible, too, which helps prolong the life of a device.

Zebra Technologies TC72 can be charged by sliding the device off a robust charging mount, causing far less wear and tear than inserting cables.

Conclusion

We hope you’re convinced that consumer models are often a fragile and precarious option for your business mobile devices, compared to rugged counterparts. The data says it all: a rugged device chosen to match the requirements of your business is likely to last three times longer than a consumer device [1].

So why do people persist with consumer devices?

Undoubtedly, it is down to cost. Initial outlay for consumer devices is less than for rugged counterparts. However, research by tech market intelligence company VDC shows that when you take into account the full cost of ownership ­– initial outlay, deployment, training, support and productivity loss caused by downtime ­– rugged devices have a 52.7% lower total cost of ownership than consumer devices over five years [1].

Our view? When you consider our nine ways consumer devices commonly fail and take into account the true cost of ownership, making the right choice is easy.

It’s rugged every time.

Take a more detailed look at the consumer versus enterprise phone debate, and make an informed choice for your business, by reading our white paper.

[1] Data and sources available at Nuffield Technologies White Paper Consumer vs Enterprise.

Why Rugged Phone Cases Are Not the Answer for Your Business

Broken phone showing mobile rugged phone cases don't work

At first glance, rugged phone cases may seem like a reasonable idea. Simply add a heavy-duty outer shell to a standard mobile phone and – in one step – you have a cut-price rugged mobile that will stand up to the rough and tumble of your workplace. Perhaps this approach will enable you to redeploy existing devices as ‘rugged’, or encourage a ‘bring your own device’ (BYOD) policy.

Perhaps.

But, as with many apparently simple solutions, when you delve deeper it gets more complicated. In fact, we suggest you think twice before following this route. For light enterprise use – perhaps in non-customer-facing office environments – it just might suit. But for businesses where phones are likely to experience intensive or rough handling, and where uninterrupted performance is paramount, you should consider a truly rugged option.

Here’s five reasons why you should not use rugged phone cases with consumer phones for your business.

1) Your phone will not be truly rugged

We’ll start with our most important point. A standard phone with a ruggedised case is not truly rugged. To understand why, it’s important to understand what makes a phone rugged.

Firstly, a rugged phone will have exceptional ingress protection, preventing solids and liquids entering the device. In most cases, rugged cases simply cannot compete with the hi-spec seals offered by good-quality rugged phones.

Secondly, a rugged phone will withstand drops and shocks without damage to exterior or interior components. Standard phones with rugged cases may protect against some drops, but will not offer the same level of protection against internal damage. As we have mentioned in another post, this is because rugged phones are built from the inside out, with resilient components such as shock-resistant memory. It’s this approach that protects against jarring falls; in other words, it has little to do with outer casings. With one survey of 2000 people suggesting people drop their phones on the ground an average of four times per week, it’s clear this is a crucial difference from the point of view of a phone’s potential lifespan.

There is also a third criteria relating to ruggedness: temperature. Some rugged devices can withstand extreme heat and cold, using sophisticated temperature level controls and even internal heaters. Simple rugged phone cases will not introduce this level of functionality or cope with temperatures ranging from 14° F to 122° F/-10° C to +50° C, which is standard for many rugged phones.

A phone standing upright in the snow, particles of snow covering the screen.
Snow problem? A consumer device – even with a rugged case – may fail at extreme temperatures. Standard rugged devices, however, can typically cope with temperatures from -10° C to +50° C.

2) Your battery may not last very long or work properly

For many businesses, the battery life of workers’ phones is critical. Loss of charge during a shift could result in hours of lost productivity.

Rugged mobile batteries often have higher capacities than consumer models. Also, at the end of a battery’s life – typically two to three years – a rugged battery can be replaced, extending the life of the device for years to come. This is not the case for many consumer devices; you may find, after two to three years, the battery function has declined significantly and the phone is no longer practical.

Rugged phone batteries are also more versatile. For instance, the ‘hot swap’ function, where batteries are swapped without powering down the device, can make all the difference to operational efficiency.

Finally, rugged phone cases can also stop your phone’s battery from working properly. This is because a battery typically dissipates heat through the casing, and an extra case will slow down this process. Consequently, the phone will heat up and run more slowly, due to thermal throttling, which means it will take longer to perform essential tasks – draining your battery.

You can solve this problem by removing the case. That, of course, takes you back to square one…

3) Charging your phone is going to become an issue

With consumer phones, charging commonly involves plugging and unplugging wires. This places a strain on the fragile charger pins, which can become damaged and operate inconsistently or not at all. As well as being easy to break, the charging port on most consumer phones is a weakness in terms of moisture and particle ingress.

Most truly rugged devices do not have a charging port. Instead, they use a dedicated charging cradle where the user simply slides the phone on and off robust pins. No wires feature. These highly adaptable devices are also backwards and forwards compatible, and can be mounted in vehicles. Many also come with multiple docking options, so you can charge several phones in one location.

A rugged phone, reverse side, showing the robust charging mechanism, which is a superior option to consumer phone charging options – even if rugged phone cases are used.
Rugged phones like the one above can be charged by simply sliding the device off a robust charging mount. This involves far less wear and tear than charging solutions for consumer phones.

In other words, when working with rugged devices in a business environment, the charging method is likely to work consistently, be freely available, and won’t pose a danger to the lifespan of your phone. For consumer devices, this isn’t necessarily going to be the case.

Yes, there is the wireless charging option, but, unfortunately, this is unacceptably slow for most businesses. And it’s made all the more slow by the addition of rugged phone cases, which may slow down the charging process.

4) It’s going to cost more than you think

Rugged cases don’t come cheap. In fact, the highest-quality models usually add a significant sum to the cost of a smartphone. This fact should be considered when comparing prices of rugged versus consumer options.

You’ll also need to address the issue of replacing phones. According to VDC Research, the annual failure rate for consumer-grade devices in enterprise environments is three times higher than for rugged phones. Even if we allow that consumer models in rugged phone cases allow some protection, they clearly aren’t going to perform as well as a rugged phone. You’ll be making more repairs and buying more phones – and paying the associated price.

Finally, the shelf life of consumer phones is often 18 months, with support available for three years or less. This means they are going to need replacing more often than rugged phones, some of which have a shelf life of five years with support available for a further five years after the phone is no longer on sale.

Going down the consumer phone / rugged case route is going to cost you. And it may well get complicated. You’ll have a mixed fleet, made up of different phones with all the implications that holds for operating systems, apps and chargers.

5) It’s not as good for the environment

We’re betting your company has a well-thought-out sustainability policy. If so, it’s going to be tough to justify the use of consumer mobiles over rugged devices.

Point 4 above reveals the short shelf life of consumer phones compared to rugged models. This throw-away-and-replace culture will contribute to the 40m tonnes of e-waste produced annually; waste that is considered hazardous and a threat to both ecosystems and human health.

Rugged phone cases are going to do little to make this better. In fact, they are going to contribute to the waste, worsening the situation.

A worker in a hard hat using a rugged phone, which will have far greater longevity than consumer models used with rugged phone cases.
Longevity is a crucial factor when considering e-waste and the environment. The rugged phone above may last for 10 years; consumer devices – even with rugged cases – could last for as little as 18 months.

In conclusion

We hope these five points convince you that, for the vast majority of businesses, going down the rugged route offers better performance, fewer failures and – ultimately – better value for money.

If you’d like to take a deeper dive into the consumer-versus-enterprise-device debate, read our white paper. It’s a great starting point for understanding the true benefit rugged devices will bring to your business, backed up by studies and data.

Nuffield Technologies can help introduce the right rugged technologies to your business, to maximise profits and productivity. We offer preferential rates on hardware from leading enterprise brands and can design bespoke software and apps tailored to your unique needs.

What Makes a Rugged Mobile ‘Rugged’?

Mountain range rugged landscape

‘Durable’ and ‘robust’ are words commonly used in marketing and the media to describe mobile devices. However, anyone procuring technology for a business will be right to look for something more precise.

So, what exactly is a rugged device and how can you tell when you have one in your hands?

Fortunately, there are ways to pin down that definition and make an educated choice for your business. In this short guide, we’ll look at what makes a device rugged. We’ll also examine MIL-STD 810G* and IP ratings, as well as details around performance at different temperatures, to help you ensure you’re getting something that will stand up to the stresses and strains of your workplace for years to come – and adds up to a great return on your investment.

Zebra L10 range of rugged Android tablets
Zebra L10 range of rugged Android tablets

Rugged: A Definition

In its simplest terms, a rugged device will work in challenging environments without failure. This is because good-quality rugged devices are toughened, with a stronger screen, thicker case and tighter seals, to protect against water, shock, vibration, dust and other potentially harmful factors.

However, they are not simply standard devices wrapped in a hard outer shell. Rather, a quality rugged device is designed for robustness from the inside out. Here’s one example of this inside out approach: many rugged devices have solid state hard drives (SSD) rather than hard disk drives (HDD), because SSDs have no moving parts and a high degree of shock resistance.

Some websites refer to three classes of rugged phones: ‘semi rugged’, ‘fully rugged’ and ‘ultra rugged’. In our view, identifying between these vague definitions quickly gets confusing. A far more precise approach is to take a close look at the factors mentioned in the introduction that truly measure a phone’s ruggedness: MIL-STD 810G certification, IP ratings, and performance across different temperature ranges. Once you understand these, you’ll be in a good place to assess the true ruggedness of a phone.

What is an IP Rating?

Ingress Protection (IP) ratings have been developed by the European Committee for Electro Technical Standardization to describe the environmental protection offered by a device’s enclosure.

There are two things we need to keep out of our devices – solids and liquids. IP ratings describe a device’s resistance to each of these.

  • Protection Against Solids is rated from 0 to 6, with zero offering no protection and six offering total protection against dust.
  • Protection Against Liquids is rated from 0-8, with zero offering no protection and eight protecting against long periods of immersion under pressure.
Guide to IP rating numbers

The actual IP rating you’ll see on a phone packaging or marketing materials is made up of two numbers, the first of which addresses solids and the second liquids. For instance, IP67 would offer a solid protection of 6 and a liquid protection of 7.

To put this into context, according to VDC Research a device should be rated at a minimum of IP54 to be considered fully rugged. However, rugged expert Zebra recommends a rating of at least IP65 to ensure the longest life for your rugged tech and a suitable return on investment. This provides a sufficient level of ruggedness against dust and protects against water from any direction, so will protect against spills. However, it will not protect against immersion in water, so if this is important seek a higher rating.

What is MIL-STD 810g?

What would happen to your device’s functionality if it were dropped again and again from height? The correct answer should be very little at all, providing it has passed the MIL-STD 810G drop test. This is a rating designed by the US Department of Defense and is used to ensure technical equipment can withstand being dropped from four feet, onto two inches of plywood over concrete, at various angles.

There are a wide range of MIL-STD 810G tests, ranging from the ‘drop’ or ‘shock’ test outlined above (these terms refer to the same test) to various others measuring the effects of humidity, rain, vibration, immersion and more. When reading a MIL-STD 810G rating, ensure you know which test or tests it refers to and don’t assume it has passed them all.

Also, in the case of all tests, the devil really is in the detail. For instance, while the MIL-STD 810G drop test involves a drop onto plywood (the most common ground material in military installations) over concrete, the industry standard for phones is a drop straight onto concrete. Look out for this in detailed specs of any product you intend to buy. If it says ‘hard surface’ and not specifically concrete it almost certainly isn’t concrete, and the phone in question may not be tough enough for you.

Bear in mind also that by far the most common MIL-STD 810G test in relation to rugged technology is the shock / drop test; the industry typically uses the IP classification for ratings concerned with ingress.

Zebra E10 tablet being dropped onto concrete
Zebra E10 tablet being dropped onto concrete floor

What do you need to know about temperature?

Will a device remain functional in extreme heat or cold? While this information may not be given with reference to a particular industry standard or accreditation, any worthwhile rugged device will explicitly state the temperatures at which it will remain fully operational. A typical rugged device may include a range from -10° C to +50° C (14° F to 122° F). However, if your employees are working in cold storage environments, you’ll want your devices to operate as low as -30°C (-22°F). For a device to operate at this temperature, an internal heater is usually required.

Putting it all together

As a minimum, we recommend that your rugged phone has an Ingress Protection rating of at least IP 65 and has passed the MIL-STD 810G drop test, with a specific mention of a four-foot fall to concrete. Of course, this is a minimum requirement and you must think carefully about your needs in terms of ruggedness, particularly with reference to water ingress.

However, a word of caution. While IP ratings are achieved via independent certification, MIL STD 810G can be verified ‘in house’. This clearly isn’t ideal from a consumer point of view, so what can you do?

We recommend you ask two questions to any company selling rugged computers:

1) What tests do you or the manufacturer regularly undertake to ensure your technology is sufficiently rugged?

2) Is your warranty based on the product's IP rating and MIL STD 810G rating? For instance, if you drop the device from up to four feet onto concrete within the warranty period, is it covered? (If the answer is yes then the company is ‘putting its money where its mouth it’; if no, you might want to question why.)

You’ll also want to check reputable reviews of the company and of its products.

Nuffield Technologies helps businesses across many sectors source high-performing rugged technology that confirms to stringent tests according to both the Ingress Protection and MIL STD 810g standards. We can share detailed specifications of all of our devices’ rugged features and rugged tests with full transparency, to help ensure you are procuring fit-for-purpose technology for your business.

* Note: MIL STD 810G was superseded by MIL STD 810H in January 2019. However, with the majority of devices still testing to MIL STD 810G, we have used this standard to illustrate our post. As MIL STD 810H becomes more widely adopted, we will update this post to reflect the new standard.

How to Pick the Right Mobile Devices for Your Warehouse Operations – And Vastly Improve Productivity

Warehouse shelving stacked with boxes

When searching for technology to improve warehouse operations, it’s tempting to dive right in and see what the market has to offer. However, we’re convinced this is not the right way to approach this major business decision. We suggest that in the quest for the perfect technology for your warehouse, you put all thoughts of that technology aside for the time being and concentrate instead on your business needs. What are the challenges you need the technology to solve? And what specific working conditions need to be taken into account?

Adopting this approach is going to help keep the focus on solving your specific challenges when you do start looking at the market. It will also help keep you on budget by potentially avoiding attractive but costly features that will do little to improve your warehouse operations.

Here are the main things to consider before you begin your search.

What do you need the devices for?

Your answer will almost certainly include barcode data capture. However, there are ‘horses for courses’. If you’re reading a high volume of barcodes and RFID tags every day, speed and accuracy will be paramount – and enterprise models will be the way to go. According to Zebra Technologies, tests show that enterprise-level readers capture barcodes 20-50 times faster than consumer equivalents, which often use the device camera instead of a dedicated barcode scanner. But it’s not just about speed. Will you need to capture 1D and 2D barcodes? Is capturing data and measuring metrics in real time important to you?

Zebra Technologies TC72 and TC77 offer fast capture of printed and electronic 1D and 2D barcodes.

Of course, there will be more to your rugged tech requirements than barcodes. You may need the device to take signatures, photograph damage on received goods, print labels and perhaps act as a two-way radio to enhance team communications. Draw up that wish list as precisely as possible before your search begins.

And think long-term. Perhaps you will need certain functions in the future to improve warehouse operations? Planning ahead will future proof your investment.

How will your workers use devices?

Ask these questions about how your employees will access and use devices when working:

  • Will they wear gloves? Many devices have high-sensitivity touch screens or physical buttons to ensure this isn’t a problem.
  • Will they need both hands to work? If so, choose wearable technology and voice-activated applications.
  • Will they be moving in and out of vehicles, for instance forklifts? Ensure robust mounting options are available, so a device can be clipped in and pulled out swiftly.
  • Do they need to access barcodes in awkward spaces? Look out for models with long-range scanners or small-form factors, for quick and easy scanning.
  • Are many of your people seasonal workers? According to this report, using the familiar Android operating system will potentially save you days of time training employees.

What unique challenges does your workplace present?

Warehouses are not friendly environments for mobile devices. Your tech may need to deal with countless drops, spills, extreme temperatures and contact with hazardous substances. In the age of COVID-19, withstanding harsh cleaning regimes with chemical-based wipes will also be a factor.

But there’s good news. Unlike consumer devices, reputable enterprise-level devices go through incredibly robust stress tests. Look out for MIL-STD-810G-certified devices. This U.S. Military Standard certification method can be deployed to test devices across many criteria including drops, dust contamination, extreme cold and more. There are various types and levels of protection that qualify for the standard, so read carefully and assess your needs against a device’s MIL-STD-810G certification.

It is vital to consider the environment in which your mobile devices will be used.

Finally, what combination of WiFi, mobile data or Bluetooth will you need to ensure your device will be operational both inside and outside your building?

What are your power needs?

Devices that have run out of battery provide zero functionality, slow down operations and frustrate your workforce. Therefore, you need to think about hard what battery requirements you’ll need to keep your people working.

If workers are regularly on the move and won’t have access to charging bays, you’ll need the extended battery life enterprise devices offer (up to 14 hours of hard work for some models).

But it’s not just about high-capacity batteries. Some models feature a warm swop mode, which allows users to change a battery without having to power down the device or close apps. Others will offer the convenience of ‘pogo’ charging pins, so they can be swiftly dropped into a cradle to charge, removing the need to fiddle with wires. Meanwhile, battery metrics will give you advanced warning of underperforming or failing batteries. All of these power features can help to keep warehouse operations running smoothly.

Finally, don’t forget your chargers. Brands that also offer multislot charging accessories will keep more phones powering up and save your employees from hunting for a free connection.

What level of support and repair do you need?

Are you happy hanging on for a week or even several weeks for vital repairs, or waiting on a support line while interminable music plays? It’s a leading question, of course, and the answer will almost certainly be no. If your warehouse is relying on tech to function, then problems need to be solved quickly to ensure continued productivity.

Reputable providers will offer certified repairs with authorised parts, and security and software/firmware updates. Many will also offer various types of repair plans, with options to suit your budget. The gold standard – and most expensive – will be around-the-clock support, and next business day ‘like new’ device replacement loaded with all your apps and settings.

While a more modestly priced three-day repair turnaround may well be fine for you, think carefully; you’ll need to weigh up the loss of business any downtime will incur against the price of any plan.

How is this new tech meeting your sustainability targets?

When it comes to warehouse operations, it’s clear that enterprise-level technology far outperforms consumer equivalents. The good news for your corporate social responsibility commitments is that it will also be a far more sustainable option . Here’s why.

Consumer devices are designed for rapid turnover. After 12 months, a new model may supersede the previous one, with limited support thereafter for the legacy devices. By contrast, the best enterprise solutions will have a longer life cycle. For instance, one provider we work with typically makes their devices available to purchase for a minimum of three years, with operating system support available for a further three years after they are retired from sale. Some of their models are even available for sale for five years, with a further five years of operating system support. In this case, there’s a full decade of support, considerably extending the shelf life.

Rugged technology will outlast consumer options, making them a more environmentally friendly choice.

Finally, enterprise devices are likely to be backwards compatible with accessories such as cables, charging cradles and batteries. This will reduce your need for additional purchases if you upgrade.

What next?

Of course, once you begin actively researching technology for improving warehouse operations, you may find additional features and benefits you’ll want to add to your ‘wish list’. But start by answering the questions in this post and you’ll maintain a tight focus on what you’ll really need to improve productivity.

Nuffield Technologies can help introduce the right rugged technologies to your warehouse operations, to maximise profits and productivity. We offer preferential rates on hardware from leading enterprise brands and can design bespoke software and apps tailored to your unique needs.

How to Upgrade Windows® CE Mobile Apps to Android™: A Step by Step Guide for Businesses

How to Upgrade Windows® CE Mobile Apps to Android™: A Step by Step Guide for Businesses

Migrating to next-generation platforms is essential, but it can also be a tricky process. In this guide, we outline our tried-and-tested approach for getting the job done on time and on budget – so you can deliver an upgrade that will help give your business an edge for years to come.

Learn how to transition your apps in our step-by-step guide – and find out how you can get started now.

Download the guide now

Choosing an Operating System for Your Business Mobile Devices? Here’s Why Android Beats iOS Every Time

Landscape phone showing Android logo as the right operating system for your business

Selecting an operating system for business devices is something you want to get right the first time. There’s a lot riding on your decision, in terms of the initial investment, ongoing maintenance costs, and the benefits you’ll enjoy from your new tech. However, once you’ve examined the options available, we believe it’s actually a simple decision to make. In fact, by the time you finish this article, we’re convinced you’ll agree with us that there’s one obvious choice.

A few years ago Microsoft was the key player for mobile business devices, with Windows CE and Windows mobile devices dominating the enterprise mobility market. However, the rise of iOS and Android has left Microsoft far behind, and with most enterprise manufacturers switching to Android, Microsoft is phasing out support for much of its mobile device software.

That leaves two options for businesses investing in a new device fleet or migrating from Microsoft: iOS and Android. There’s a good chance that you have a preference for Apple devices: its iconic products are stylish, sleek and contained in a seamless closed system. However, the iOS features that are virtues for consumers do not translate as benefits for enterprise users – quite the contrary, in fact, as you’ll discover below. Our experience in building mobile business software and deploying fleets of devices shows that Android is far more adaptable to the rigours of the enterprise market and is usually the right operating system for business users.

Here’s why you should choose Android over iOS

1. Cost

Android is responsible for an explosion in affordable smart devices. As manufacturers continue to push the envelope at the premium end of the market, the trickle-down effect of technology has resulted in good quality and inexpensive smartphones for every budget. However purchase cost is only one part of the equation, you also need to consider the total cost of ownership over the projected life of your device fleet, factoring in the serviceable life of the devices and the cost of damaged, lost and stolen devices.

Android devices provide value in both purchase price and total cost of ownership.

2. Support and Maintenance

When choosing any device, you should always look at the support period for security updates. All manufacturers will eventually stop publishing security updates for their devices, leaving them vulnerable to failure and attack thereafter. Apple is very good at supporting older devices, with most devices being supported for 5-6 years before the operating system stops receiving updates, but they do not guarantee the period over which devices bought now will be supported. Consumer Android devices typically receive 3 years support before being abandoned. However, the Android Enterprise Recommended programme defines the minimum support length for rugged devices as 5 years, and the best enterprise Android devices on the market now have support lifecycles guaranteed for 10 years.

It’s also important to consider how the performance of devices will degrade over the support period. Apple devices have fixed batteries which can’t be replaced, which means that the performance will gradually deteriorate and may lead to your workers not being able to complete a shift before they have to recharge the device. Apple is notorious for reducing the processing power of older devices in an attempt to mitigate this problem, so the device you buy now may not be able to run your business apps effectively for the entire life of the device. Conversely, rugged Android devices usually have removable batteries, so they can be replaced before battery degradation becomes a problem.

3. Choice

iOS runs only on Apple devices. You are limited to iPhones, iPads and a few peripherals such as smartwatches, all of which are inherently designed for the consumer market and as such not suited for many workplace environments.

Android devices come in all shapes and sizes, with varying battery life, durability, aesthetics, reliability, performance, storage capacity and other specialist features. From rugged and waterproof tough phones suitable for use in any outdoor and demanding environment, to high-end tablets for sales teams, there is an Android device suited to every job role. Android also has specialist devices for specific applications, such as devices with high-performance barcode scanners, wearable devices and devices built for use in hazardous areas.

Android is hugely versatile: it can be deployed in a wide range of rugged devices, including the arm-mounted computer and integrated ring scanner pictured above.

4. Industrial features

As little as 10 years ago, if you were going to deploy a fleet tracking or logistics solution you would be looking at industrial mobile options which, at the time, was pretty much the exclusive domain of Windows Mobile (CE) ruggedised devices. Times have changed and mainstream manufacturers like Motorola, Intermec, Panasonic and Zebra Technologies have standardised their new offerings on Android. These products can integrate laser barcode scanners, NFC, have great battery life, docking chargers and hot swappable batteries.

The most significant difference between iOS and Android in this regard is the availability of rugged devices. These are devices which have been designed and tested to withstand vibration, shock, dirt, dust, moisture and chemicals. They are also built for the rugged environment: as an example, many models have much higher maximum volume than an iPhone, which may not be heard even at full volume in a noisy warehouse.

By comparison, an iPhone may look great, but is simply not built for challenging enterprise environments. One company proved this by comparing an enterprise model with an iPhone in a simulated rugged environment. After 26 drops at four feet, the rugged device was fully operational. The iPhone, meanwhile, saw pieces break off, volume button failure, charging problems and rattling noises, to name just some of the failures.

Some businesses try to circumvent this issue with rugged cases, but these only solve part of the problem. They may offer some external protection against drops, but internal components are still prone to damage from sudden shock. Also, fogging and condensation behind the case are frequently a problem.

Rugged by name, rugged by nature: this Zebra WT6000 wearable computer is designed to withstand 1000 tumbles at 0.5m.

5. Security

In the early days of smartphone technology, iOS was the clear leader in terms of security. From launch, they supported business grade features to ensure that data was not compromised on mobile devices, such as encryption and VPN support. It took Android a long time to catch up with Apple on this front, and there is still a prevailing superstition that iOS is better than Android when it comes to security. However, this is simply not the case any more. Android Enterprise has regularly scored higher than iOS in recent years in the Gartner security reports and continues to make strides with both hardware and software security.

One common misconception when it comes to security is that iOS is more secure than Android because it is closed source. In reality, the opposite of this is true. Because Android is open source, anyone in the world can look for and find bugs and vulnerabilities in the operating system, often before new versions of the OS are released. This might seem like a bad thing, but because Google pays up to a million dollars for reporting a vulnerability, there is an army of developers worldwide looking for and reporting exploits in the operating system.

The open source nature of Android also means that manufacturers have the ability to add additional security features above and beyond what the operating system provides. Good examples of this are Samsung Knox and Zebra Mobility Extensions, which both add extra configurable features which help businesses to reduce their potential for attack.

6. Familiarity

We’ve mentioned this point in a previous blog post, but it deserves mentioning again. 84.8% of mobile users have Android phones and this familiarity is a powerful factor when choosing an operating system for business devices. Android is the most dominant mobile operating system by far, and it's likely that most of your employees are already using an Android device. This means that they will get up to speed with your new devices more quickly, which one report suggests can cut training time down from days to hours when compared to less familiar systems. A new generation of digitally proficient workers are entering the workplace who will expect the same high quality of digital tools they already use in their personal life. By empowering your employees with the right tools for the job, and tools that they already understand, they will be more productive.

7. Customisation

Customisation has been a core feature of Android since its inception, and one that has only recently been introduced to iOS at any meaningful level. Both operating systems now have the ability to achieve simple customisation steps, such as replacing the wallpaper with your company logo, putting a standard set of company apps on the homescreen, and banishing unwanted or little used apps to a folder in their app drawer.

However Android’s deep support for customisation gives businesses much more control over the information and functionality that is available to their users. On Android it is possible to completely change the user’s home screen to present whatever you want it to display, and make it a hub for your business’s operations, rather than it simply be a launcher with which to access other applications. It is possible to replace or remove most parts of the operating system’s user interface, and to replace core parts of the operating system such as the keyboard. This gives you complete control over what your users can do on their devices, as well as opening up more options for users with diverse needs. You can also control exactly what notifications and settings the user is able to see and interact with, and which peripherals the user is able to connect to the device, allowing you to minimise distractions and enhance productivity as well as keeping your data and devices secure.

8. Storage expansion

This is a simple difference, but a very important one in a business context. Most Android handsets offer expandable storage using inexpensive microSD cards allowing you to carry more data or install more apps without upgrading the entire handset. We find this particularly useful for users who need to load significant quantities of reference data on the device, or who frequently take photos and videos on the go. On iOS this is not possible, and devices’ storage cannot be expanded beyond the original specification.

9. Batteries and charging

As previously mentioned, it is not possible to change the battery on an iOS device. As well as limiting the effective lifespan of the device, this has an impact in day to day use. Many enterprise grade Android devices have the ability to change the battery on the go. Some devices even support being able to swap the battery without turning off the device, known as hot-swapping. This means that if the device runs out of battery in the middle of a shift, the user can simply change the battery and carry on working, meaning that the devices can be run continuously. With an iOS device, the user would be forced to charge the device, meaning that either more devices are needed to support continuous work, or that they must spend part of their day tethered to a charger.

Android devices also have better support for various types of charger, such as vehicle mounted cradles and independent battery chargers, which can charge batteries without them being connected to the device, all of which lead to devices being in service for longer periods of time, therefore representing better return on investment.

10. Customisable buttons

At the bottom of any Android device there are a trio of soft key navigation controls – back, home and multitasking. These keys, and particularly the back key, are one of Androids biggest differentiators from other operating systems providing a consistent navigation approach across the entire system. Whilst this may seem a minor detail, they are a very powerful feature of the intuitive Android experience.

Moreover some Android devices, particularly the ruggedised and industrial versions, have additional hard keys that can be configured for a variety of purposes such as shortcuts to apps, lone worker panic alarms or barcode scanners. Good examples of this type of products are the Panasonic FZ-B2 or the Zebra TC25.

Zebra Technologies’ TC25 allows instant point-and-shoot capture of any electronic or printed barcode in virtually any condition.

11. Android Enterprise

Android Enterprise is Google’s programme that focuses on using Android devices in the workplace, and represents their commitment to best-of-class experience for enterprise mobility. Through the programme, they continuously add features designed specifically for business use. The ability to deploy an extensive range of policy controls on the device is extremely useful for managing employee devices in the field, and built in layers of security prevent intrusions so you can be confident your data is safe.

Android Enterprise offers multiple methods for deploying devices in your business, such as Work Profile which lets staff keep their personal and work lives securely separated on one device. Other features include the ability to rapidly set up hundreds of devices using an NFC tag to install a custom set of applications and settings, and the ability to use Mobile Device Management software to monitor the status of devices in the field, apply security policies remotely and ensure that devices are being used appropriately.

Also included under the Android Enterprise banner is the Android Enterprise Recommended programme, which identifies devices and services that meet a set of requirements that mean that they are suitable for use in a business environment. By choosing devices from this list, you can be certain that you are making a good choice for your business.

Nuffield Technologies offers a full solution – from consultancy to procurement and software development – for businesses looking to boost their performance with rugged technology. We have excellent relationships with leading suppliers and can help you find a cost-effective solution to upgrading your operations.